Skip to main content

Mortgage Lender Lawsuits


1. Convey Clear Title to the Borrower and Place the Lender’s Loan in the Lien Position Requested

Maryland Mortgage Lenders Sue for Breach of Lender Closing Instruction, Negligence Duing Real Estate Settlement, and Title Agent Malpractice.To perfect the Lender’s security interest, it is the obligation of the settlement agent to convey clear title to the borrower and place the lender in the lien position that the lender has requested. In most case, the title agent must ensure that the lender has a "first lien position" providing it with top priority in foreclosing upon the property in the event that its loan goes into default. Naturally, no lender would want to extend a loan that is secured by pricey real estate only to find that it must stand in lien behind other creditors who have superior security interests.

2. Comply with Closing Instructions

Regardless of the number of settlements you have performed and the number of closing instructions you have reviewed, never assume that you know what the lender wants in a given transaction. Read these instructions very carefully before closing any loan. Arguably, the lender’s closing instructions create a contractual relationship between the lender and the title agent. At a minimum, the title agent has agreed to act as an escrow agent for the lender and to distribute loan proceeds only when the title agent is able to convey clear title to the borrower and deliver to the lender a valid and enforceable mortgage or deed of trust.

Traditionally, beyond acting as an escrow agent, a title agent’s relationship to a lender has been viewed as primarily as one in tort. However, lenders are increasingly asserting that a contractual relationship exists between a lender and a borrower, suing title agents for breach of contract for failing to comply with the closing instructions provided. Indeed, lenders today do not hesitate to blame the title agent when something goes wrong in a transaction. Beyond more traditional contractual duties dealing with the handling of escrow funds and the delivery of mortgage or deed of trust in the first (or other) lien position, some lenders seek to shift the risk and costs of a borrower defaulting on its loan to another party by including "instructions" which seek to transfer this risk of loss to the settlement agent. One now defunct sub-prime lender included the following "instruction" in its letter of closing instructions:

1.2 Compensation for Damages: Your willingness to act as the settlement attorney/officer signifies your agreement to indemnify us (whether by virtue of an insured closing letter or otherwise) for any and all damages we may suffer as a result of your negligence or your failure to comply with our instructions. If you have not provided us with an insured closing letter from each of your title companies, please forward to this office prior to closing.

Wow. This "closing instruction" essential converts unassuming title agents into title insurers who must protect the lender even if they adhered to the proper standard of care in conducting settlements. Notice that this language would require that title agents indemnify this lender for loss even where a breach of closing instruction was not due to the negligence of the title agent. Watch out for closing instructions that expand the duties of a title agent to impermissible levels and – more importantly – beware of lenders who try to sneak this fine print into your transactions. Often the best settlement is the one that you walk away from.

The legal information on Maryland real estate law, Maryland realty law, real property sales contracts, breach of real estate contract, breach of contract lawsuit, Maryland property law suit for breach of contract, lawsuit for sale of land, realtor fraud, legal negotiations, real estate sales contract, Maryland real estate purchase contract, injunction against developer real estate development, specific performance, lease agreement, settlement real estate, cloud on title, foreclosure real estate Maryland, real estate commission, legal title defects, real estate settlement, breach of contract real estate maryland, flipping real estate fraud, real estate lawsuits, residential property disputes law firm Maryland Land Title Association, real estate professional liability, negligent title agent, title insurance, title agents and abstracter errors and omissions insurance, real estate title attorney, abstracter errors, real estate settlement services, real estate fraud, real estate flipping, Real Estate Settlement Procedures, RESPA lawyer, easements, restrictive covenants, Maryland zoning and other real estate laws, is designed for informational purposes only and is not intended to constitute legal advice. Readers are advised to seek the representation of a competent real estate lawyer Maryland settlement attorney to protect their legal rights. The slogans, High-Speed Access to Legal Action, Legal Advice, Legal Counsel, Legal Protection, State & Federal Courts, Dispute & Conflict Resolution, Probate Protection, Legal News, Legal Training & Seminars, and the substantial equivalent thereof are service marks of Kramer & Connolly.